Skip to main content

RO Commentary: USA Rugby in row over leadership

I have no real knowledge of rugby and the organization that runs the sport here in the United States, USA Rugby.

I read here from gainline.us and here from Universal Sports' "The Scrum" Blog by Buzz McClain about some dissatisfaction with USA Rugby President and CEO Nigel Melville and Board Chairman Kevin Roberts.

I'll let you read and come to your own conclusions, but here my own uninformed talking points:

  • I don't care if USA XV's coach Coach Eddie O'Sullivan, Melville and Roberts aren't American. That never has been a sufficient criteria for a coach or an administrator of any sport in the United States. Having well qualified individuals such as these can only help, not hurt American Rugby. I think we need their knowledge and expertise having coached or administered the game of rugby at the highest levels in the rugby-playing world.
  • If the articles are true as written, specifically that the Congress that elects the USA Rugby CEO and the Board and its chairman are powerless and voiceless, it should be recitified immediately. However, just because there are voices of dissent does not mean a change in course is in order.
  • However passionate a USA Rugby Chairman is of his heritage and his sport, he should not be the author of articles showing another country how it can leverage its strengths to further the very game he oversees in a different country.
  • That being said, if Division III Mount Union's Athletic Director penned an article on how Ohio State can win the BCS National Championship, would there be such an uproar? From the folks in Alliance, OH likely, but it would not be the lead story on ESPN.
  • I suspect that much of the discontent exists because of the autonomy and internal pride territorial unions have because they probably are the coach, ref and administrator all in one at the lower levels. This makes them well-informed, passionate and tireless advocates seeking the acknowledgement they deserve for their efforts. That, as an American I DO understand. We don't like it if we're pulling the cart and we don't have a say in where it's going. That's just a guess folks. I admit I don't really know what I am talking about.
  • Finally, I think the 800-pound gorilla in all this is NCAA college rugby, which may in time have the resources, following and talent pool to make USA Rugby bend to its needs. The only domestic Rugby on TV at the moment on any channel is college rugby if I'm not mistaken. It's a Division I sport at a few Universities across the nation and is a club sport at many others. Since the college model is so well known (I won't say the best route to professional rugby) it is likely that an informed electorate of USA Rugby's Congress would quickly latch on to a college-first concept that would be easy to understand and conducive to rapid growth in the short term with TV sponsorships and exposure.

Just my opinions. I invite yours.

RO

Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Invictus a movie worth watching

Go out and rent Invictus , the movie about the 1995 Rugby World Cup in South Africa. Starring Matt Damon as Springbok Francois Pienaar and Morgan Freeman as then-President Nelson Mandela. It is an inspirational movie along the lines of what Miracle did to magnify the accomplishments of the US Olympic Ice Hockey team in 1980. However, as Pienaar points out in this Times UK article , the Springbok team portrayed in the movie was quite different than in real life. That South African side was very capable of winning a World Cup, and though a surprise, it was not as earth shattering as the US hockey team gold medal in Lake Placid. However, politically, the Springbok victory was enormous for the emerging nation. Clint Eastwood's film does an outstanding job of highlighting Mandela's 27-year imprisonment on Robben Island, and Freeman, who always seems to play the wise man in a room of fools, expertly charts the course of unity by testing his relationship with his cabinet and ...
Post a Comment
Read more

RO Commentary: Thoughts on Sharks-Crusaders Rugby game

Remember the date: 27 March 2011. I hope all who were watching the Sharks-Crusaders SupeRugby match from Twickenham knew what was happening: a match between the Manchester United and FC Barcelona of the Rugby Union world. It was a date that will live in history as the first SupeRugby game played in the Northern Hemisphere, which saw the Crusaders beat the Sharks 44-28 . The Durban-based Sharks and the Christchurch-based Crusaders came to Twickenham in England to play the game postponed from earlier this season because of the earthquake on South Island that affected Christchurch and the surrounding area. My uninformed thoughts and observations of this historic tilt are thus: Yes, it seems that Sonny Bill Williams is the real deal. If you don't know by now, fellow Americans think the next Jonah Lomu. OK, bad analogy for those of you that don't know Rugby. Think the next A-Rod in baseball, the next Peyton Manning in football or the next Kobe Bryant in basketball. What I liked...
Post a Comment
Read more